Scientists have solved the mystery of one of the animal kingdom’s most disproportionately large penises thanks to a Dutch retiree recording bat sex in a church attic.

The serotine bat does not use its strangely large penis for penetration, but instead as a “copulatory arm” during mating, a European team of researchers said on Monday.

This marks the first time that a mammal has been documented reproducing without having penetrative sex, the researchers added.

The serotine bat, which has a wingspan of more than 14 inches, is common in woodlands across Europe and Asia.

Nicolas Fasel, a researcher at Switzerland‘s University of Lausanne, told Agence France-Presse that his team had been working on the bat for years and had observed that its “penis is super long when it is erect.”

Their penises are around seven times longer than the vaginas of female serotine bats, the scientists measured.

Stranger still, the head of the penis expands into the shape of a heart, making it seven times wider than their partners’ vaginas.

The scientists were baffled.

“There is no way it can penetrate with this structure,” said Fasel, the first author of a new study in the journal Current Biology.

Relatively little is known about how bats mate because it is difficult to observe, and the scientists could not see a way of solving this mystery.

But then Fasel received a strange-looking email.

“A bat porn box”

“Penis” was the first word of the email’s subject line, followed by something in Dutch, then the word “Eptesicus.”

“So I was thinking, OK, that looks like spam,” Fasel said.

However, Eptesicus is the genus of the serotine bat, so Fasel risked opening the email and watching the videos inside.

“Then I was really amazed because we had our answer,” he said.

The email was from Jan Jeucken, a retiree with no scientific background who lives in the southern village of Castenray in the Netherlands.

Jeucken had become interested in a population of serotine bats living in the attic of a local church, and had set up cameras recording huge amounts of footage.

Fasel said Jeucken’s “passion made him the best guy” to understand the bats, and the retiree was named as a co-author of the study.

The researchers analyzed 93 mating events in the church attic, as well as four recorded at a bat rehabilitation center in war-torn Ukraine.

By filming through a grid that the bats climbed on, the researchers were able to observe them mating.

Female serotine bats have a large membrane between their tail and ankles which they can use to shield their genitals.

During mating, the males grab the females by the nape and use their large penises like an extra arm to reach around and remove this membrane, the researchers said.

“We postulate that the hair present on the terminal swelling serves as a sensor to help find the vulva,” the study’s authors write. “During this time we noted several social calls, probably emitted by the female.”

Then follows a long, still embrace called “contact mating,” during which sperm is transferred.

While this form of reproduction — also called “cloacal kissing” — is common in birds, it had never previously been observed in a mammal.

For serotine bats, the process takes some time. The average session was 53 minutes, but the longest lasted nearly 13 hours.

“It’s a really weird reproductive strategy, but bats are weird and have a lot of weird reproductive strategies,” Patty Brennan, a biologist at Mount Holyoke College who was not involved in the study, told the New York Times, adding: “I think that there are probably quite a lot of weird morphologies and behaviors that we just don’t know anything about.”

Fasel speculated that the female bats could use their unusually long cervixes to hold onto the sperm of several different males for months before choosing which male they bear offspring with.

It is possible that other bat species mate without penetration, Fasel said, adding more research was needed.

“We could see that there are many, many species with quite strange penises,” he said.

The authors concluded that the study revealed “a novel copulatory pattern in mammals,” adding that further investigation should focus on male competition as well as the role played by pre- and post-copulatory female choice.

To better understand the mating behavior of serotine bats, Fasel told LiveScience that he and his colleagues “are trying to develop a bat porn box, which will be like an aquarium with cameras everywhere.”